All entries for Saturday 17 July 2010

July 17, 2010

Paul the Octopus

A week ago, a friend of mine (who's currently reading economics, may I add) posted the link to a BBC article talking about the probability of Paul the Octopus being psychic. His comment was something along the lines of statisticians wheeling out binomial distributions and had a rather spiteful tone to it. Of course, I see this as a personal affront to my chosen line of work. Hence, I started thinking about the best way to argue this, and of course, prove the well-known fact that economists are rubbish at probability and statistics.

I shall not delve into the technical details too much, but the first method I thought of was the frequentist method of using maximum likelihood estimators and possibly doing a hypothesis test. Sounds good right? But wait, does this give any useful information?

I've reached a point in my research now where we start considering Bayesian estimators. The SPM8 package is designed to do this - in fact Dr Nichols made some settings to use "classical" ie non-Bayesian estimators for the first simulation. So not much problem with the programming, pretty straightforward. Now the problem is, I've not done any Bayesian statistics in the first 2 years of MMORSE. So what's this all about? I was told that essentially all I need to know is Bayes Theorem and some easy manipulation/algebra. (Trust me, it's really nothing spectacular.)

So with this in mind, I started wondering how using a Bayesian approach would solve the question of a psychic cephalopod. I asked Guy today in the office and he briefly explained to me how it works. Again, Bayes theorem, sub in the required probabilities and a very rough estimation probably puts the probability at about 1 in a few hundred thousand. Hardly worth getting excited about. Will probably do some proper calculations and write-up in the near future.

I ended up spending most of the afternoon reading some articles/websites about the frequentist/Bayesian divide. Pretty interesting. I have to admit I'm turning Bayesian.

Funny how a question that seemed perfectly unrelated to my research turned out to have a lot in common eh?

July 2010

Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa Su
Jun |  Today  | Aug
         1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31   

Search this blog



Most recent comments

  • Thanks a lot! That does seem to work better! by on this entry
  • You don't need to cat /dev/null into a file to empty it, you can just use > For example: me@mine:/tm… by Mike Willis on this entry

Blog archive

Not signed in
Sign in

Powered by BlogBuilder