October 09, 2005

The long wait is over – Serenity has landed

Movie image
4 out of 5 stars

"People don't appreciate the substance of things" is a line from the final episode of the TV series Firefly, one that was never aired. I can't help feeling that it was director Joss Whedon's way of telling Fox how stupid they were for cancelling the show. But with the release of the follow-up film Serenity this week, all would seem to be right again, and Fox's presence banished. The question that must be asked however, is can one appreciate the substance of Serenity in the wake of Firefly, or for that matter, without its influence?

I cannot answer the latter part. I first watched Firefly back in April, and fell immediately in love with its rich universe, deep characters and snappy dialogue. Obviously the film cannot achieve anywhere near this amount of detail as it lasts little longer than a couple of episodes, so anyone who didn't watch Firefly won't attain the same level of understanding. More to the point, two characters – Inara and Book – appear only in small doses, and their roles are not explained at all. As well as this, Simon's portrayal has changed completely, and the film intro will cause Firefly fans much confusion. Who is this master of disguise indeed?

So maybe I can answer after all. Yes, you can appreciate it if you haven't seen Firefly, but you can't appreciate it as much. If you have watched the series, I fear you will be left feeling a bit disappointed. Serenity was never going to be as good as Firefly, for the reason stated above, but knowing this doesn't stop me thinking that it could still have been a bit better. While there is much in the way of wise-cracking, the banter which drew us into Firefly is a bit on the sparse side. The first 40 minutes were more about action sequences than storytelling - forgivable as a means of attracting a wider audience, but out of place in the context of the series. Equally there is the issue of sound in space. The series had none, as is physically correct, but it appeared (erratically) in Serenity. Once again this was included to make the film more exciting, so I see the reason even if I'd have preferred the silence. Finally, the delivery of the plot point around which the film revolved - the completion of the River storyline - seemed to me to be a bit bland. My thought process at the time was simply "oh", rather than "wow, I never expected that!"

The final worry is that this might be the end. As the film came to a close I was left with a feeling of emptiness, wondering where it can go from here. I only hope that Joss is up to the task of creating new stories as excellent as the old ones (which I'm sure he is), and that he gets that chance. I may have been overly harsh here, but only because I do appreciate the substance of things, and the substance of Firefly is more impressive than that of Serenity. But that is in no way saying that Serenity is bad. It is, in fact, the best sci-fi film I've seen in years.

- 5 comments by 1 or more people Not publicly viewable

  1. I haven't seen the film yet, but I'm now a bit dissapointed in advance that they changed things around – I guess focusing on a smaller group of characters allows more depth. I'll just have to wait and see…

    09 Oct 2005, 19:01

  2. you haven't seen it…SHAME ON YOU MAN!

    09 Oct 2005, 19:35

  3. I've not seen the series at all, but saw the movie last night and thought it was great. I'm sure I did miss bits because of not seeing Firefly, but I didn't feel like I was missing out really and just enjoyed it as a stand-alone film.

    10 Oct 2005, 10:01

  4. Cathy

    I agree that some of the characters seemed different than how they were portrayed in Firefly – Simon most notably, and I thought Wash had very few lines that seemed in-character for him.

    The "sound in space" thing was probably to cater to the more mainstream audience, who may have found it jarring to have suddenly silent shots. In deference to the fans, pedants, scientists and realism though, I'm pretty sure that all the space shots with sound (the battle, first shot of Serenity) were actually in atmosphere, and so there would have been sound in any case.

    10 Oct 2005, 18:08

  5. You could probably argue (and I did) that sound inside the ion cloud was ok. And at the start, yes – they were in atmosphere. The one that was most out of place was with the reavers – when the light came on you heard a noise, and also when they shot the cannon. Those were not in an atmosphere, and were particularly out of place considering the silence the REST of the time

    10 Oct 2005, 21:09

Add a comment

You are not allowed to comment on this entry as it has restricted commenting permissions.

October 2005

Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa Su
Sep |  Today  | Nov
               1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30

Search this blog


Most recent comments

  • Bob, I have three words for you…RIGHT FUCKING ON! except for the thing about girls…as I am a gir… by wouldn't you like to know on this entry
  • 96 seconds, expert, sayin by Brandon MacNeil on this entry
  • i use lol,omg,wtf,hehehhee,hhahahahahahha,ehem and heavy ass shit…. by Jack Aledruis Herringtonn on this entry
  • I think these phrases are very necessary, Naomi, since people OFTEN misinterprate your intentions wh… by Tim on this entry
  • holy shit dude i agree… lol… i liek use tiz as a filla w0rd n shiz lolh4x pwnt liek nubz0r lol k… by smoker on this entry

Blog archive

Not signed in
Sign in

Powered by BlogBuilder