August 12, 2006

Wrong about fees

Writing about web page http://education.guardian.co.uk/students/tuitionfees/story/0,,1840824,00.html

Neal Lawson has it wrong in quite a few ways here.

There remains a massive job to do to tackle the social inequitities Lawson describes but the new fees regime – provided this kind of misinformation can be challenged – with its requirements for generous bursary packages, actually offers the best prospect for changing this.

Several specific points:

  • variable fee repayment arrangements are effectively a graduate tax – but they are a capped graduate tax – you don't keep paying after you have repaid all that you owe.
  • the 20k debt is not a credit card style debt
  • Without the deal on fees many universities would be heading towards insolvency – a graduate tax would not deliver the money desperately needed now in HE.

Most of the rest of this is just pure speculation and really just a bit previous, eg:

Variable fees haven't yet worked as well as the government hoped.

The government has put a financial support package together – but it's clearly not working.

It's August. Fees start this September. Let's look at it in a year, three years or five years and then decide if it's working.


- One comment Not publicly viewable

  1. Matt

    Without the deal on fees many universities would be heading towards insolvency – a graduate tax would not deliver the money desperately needed now in HE.

    But hang on, I thought you said that the current arrangements are a graduate tax? So why aren't universities heading towards insolvency now? (or are they?)

    Of course, you're wrong to say that fees are equivalent to a graduate tax. Psychologically, top up fees are completely different. Being told that you'll amass at least £20,000 worth debt over three years is going to lead to a completely different risk assessment than being told you'll pay 1p in the pound more on income tax.

    Further, it is hardly controversial to suggest that variable fees haven't yet worked as the govt hoped. The name rather gives it away: the govt hoped they'd be variable, but they all seem to have ended up being the same.

    12 Aug 2006, 09:57


Add a comment

You are not allowed to comment on this entry as it has restricted commenting permissions.

August 2006

Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa Su
Jul |  Today  | Sep
   1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31         

Most recent comments

  • I am going for a second interview for administrattive position to CEO of a radio station….administ… by sherri on this entry
  • Classic Ellie! by on this entry
  • …okay, so the ace of spades isnt a face card its late and its been a long week by Ellie Clewlow on this entry
  • The track that seemed to be on constant loop at the pub I went to as a teenager… Ace of Spades – Mot… by Ellie Clewlow on this entry
  • As I did a bit of work on this in my degree, I would say that in all liklihood, the problem is not t… by on this entry

Tags

Galleries

Blog archive

Loading…

Search this blog

Last.fm Chart

Not signed in
Sign in

Powered by BlogBuilder
© MMXIX