All entries for Wednesday 22 February 2012
February 22, 2012
Workshop Tutor: Bev Walshe
Heres a summary of how I've been getting on with my action points
Thank you for your reply on my last blog.
Earlier this week, our group from Business Planning module had a presentation on our product. We were a group of 6 students, but we decided to have 2 presenters only. When preparing the presentation, I suggested creating a prezi presentation. Well, I wasn’t presenting, but at least I want to help them to create the whole concept so as to make the presentation more interesting and catchy. Interestingly, a colleague of mine who was presenting decided not to use prezi. He told me that it is easier for him to use the “conventional” PowerPoint presentation.
It reminded me of your last question regarding the drawbacks of prezi and I did some research on the internet on what people actually think about prezi.
I personally prefer prezi over PowerPoint because I think it is user-friendly tool which helps you to make the audience engaged with your topic.
However, there certainly are some disadvantages:
1. There are different types of audience – especially when it comes to serious topics, or if there are more conservative listeners who might expect you to deliver a presentation in PPT.
2. Prezi does not suit to everyone. The situation that happened in our group clearly demonstrates that not everyone is familiar or comfortable with prezi. Admittedly, people who have a problem with creating a structure of the presentation might find it difficult to use prezi. In such case, PPT presentation provides them with a clear and uniform structure in the form of slides.
3. PPT is also more user-friendly in terms of the cooperation with other softwares, such as Word or Excel.
4. The quality of the presentation can undermine the value of the content. Or even worse, people can try to cover the lack of content with the beauty of prezi. – In such case, it is up to people to realize that prezi is only a tool – first aid kit for presenters.
To sum up, undoubtedly, there are more shortcomings to mention. What I have observed so far is that prezi offers a new, unconventional way of presenting. Also, it might look like people are dividing into two camps – Prezi vs. PPT. I think, it is practical to know how to use both and to learn, which tool is more suitable for which type of presentation.
Well, at the end, it is not about what is on the screen behind your back, but the content and delivery of the presentation is what matters.
Dear Bev, I hope that I have covered all the things and action points from the beginning. Thank you very much for your valuable input and questions.