September 05, 2006

Modern Times: First week's listening

Right. It’s been over a week since Bob Dylan’s Modern Times was released. I was going to do a review on the day it came out, just to be flashy, but I didn’t have the time. Now I’ve had a better listen anyway.

1. Thunder on the Mountain
2. Spirit on the Water
3. Rollin’ and Tumblin’
4. When the Deal Goes Down
5. Someday Baby
6. Workingman’s Blues
7. Beyond the Horizon
8. Nettie Moore
9. The Levee’s Gonna Break
10. Ain’t Talkin’

Can’t be bothered to put the times for you, but it’s 63 minutes over 10 tracks, so.
This album is not a terrible disappointment. Neither is it overwhelming. As suspected, style-wise it is very close to his last two albums, in that the sound is Roots Rock & Roll all the way. People are already saying that this is the third installment of a trilogy with Time Out of Mind and Love and Theft. Dylan himself says that if anything, the trilogy starts with Love and Theft.

Modern Times opens in a, how shall I put it, grandiose way, as if to say “My last album was a masterpiece, it’s been 5 years, I’m back, look at me!”. To great relief it very quickly calms to a rolling blues jam session. Talking about about Alicia Keys in the first verse didn’t impress me at all. “Have more taste”, I think to myself. Other than that, the lyrics are up to Love and Theft standard on Thunder on the Mountain, and it’s actually a better opener than Tweedle Dee & Tweedle Dum.

On first listen the stand-out tracks are Spirit on the Water and Workingman’s Blues #2. This remains true. I’ve heard that an early reviewer remarked that there were “at least 3 masterpieces” on Modern Times”. These two, with the addition of Nettie Moore must be what he’s talking about, no others could be called masterpieces.

Spirit on the Water comes in just like Mississippi does on Love and Theft, a slow number after a brisk opener, and as soon as Dylan’s voice comes in, you know it’s going to be a classic love song. They share similar themes:
“All my powers of expression, I thought so sublime, Could never do you justice, in reason or rhyme”
“when you’re with me, I’m a thousand times happier than I could ever say.”

One thing to notice about this album, it’s much more piano driven than Love and Theft or Time out of Mind. Gone is Hammond man Augie Meyers, truly worthy of Al Cooper’s mantle. I don’t know why Dylan has made this decision, perhaps he now wants to recall artists from before the electric organ was around. Though “Spirit on the Water” is a stormer, it’s certainly not helped him throughout the album.

The intro lead guitar on Rollin’ and Tumblin’ actually hurts my ears. Though Dylan, once again, redeems himself by churning out a decent song by the end of it, the lead guitar track is never attractive. Apart from that, I think the levels are a bit awry on this one. It’s self produced, maybe that was an off day, maybe the engineer was out to lunch. It’s a sure rip straight from Muddy Waters in title, music and lyrics; it’s essentially a glorified cover, except Muddy Water’s song felt somehow more natural. God, that guitar track, what was he thinking?

Lyrically, the album pretty similar to Love and Theft,but with considerably less literary and other references (how could it fail on that score?). One I notice is “I sleep in the kitchen with my feet in the hall” which is an excerpt from an old folk song called Take a Whiff on Me, “I got a woman, six feet tall, sleepin’ in the kitchen with her feet in the hall”. Elsewhere, stories within stories abound. On the gorgeous ballad Working Man’s Blues #2, it starts out quite political, about low wages and “competition” in the veign of North Country Blues or Union Sundown, then two thirds in he infuses some love-centred lyrics, then slips in and out of the two stories. He mentions the “place I love best”, which I assume to be a reference to Minnesota. It certainly fits with the blue-collar imagery of the song. The rythym guitar on this track, all on-beat muted and choppy is a the centrepiece of what is a rare example of this band reaching the heights of the 2001 touring band. Overall, they’re nowhere near as interesting. The double-bass playing is fine (oh! just happens to be the only one who appeared on Love and Theft) but I yearn terribly for Meyers and Campbell and Sexton.

The title and first line of the chorus of “Nettie Moore” is apparantly a rip-off of a 40s song. If the title of Love and Theft expressed his love for Roots and the admition that on that album he was stealing a lot, the title of this album must be piss-take. Modern it is not. Nettie Moore is a soft song, minimalist percussion, and perhaps his finest vocal and lyrical performance on the album. Here lies the funniest quip on the album, “I’m in a cowboy band”, and a menacing “before you call me any dirty names, you better think twice” and “when I’m through with you, you’ll learn to keep your buisiness straight” reminiscent of his “I’m not quite as cool or forgiving as I sound” on Floater, that was lifted from an obscure Japanese book about a former Yakuza boss.

The drums are mainly done with brushes on this album. It’s certainly rocks less than Love and Theft. I hate to think he was losing any energy. I was thinking the other day, and a friend pointed out that Dylan is still only 65, 10 off of expected age. There’s a possible one or two albums left in him if he decides to do it. I’d be very surprised if he decided to change styles now. For some reason I really thought Love and Theft was going to be his last album. I’m glad it’s not. This is certainly worth having.
It’s three and a half stars out of five, a 7 out of 10. No more. It’s a more consistant album than Time out of Mind (Time out of Mind had way too many of what I would call “average blues-rock, and an awful closer), but then again has nothing to compete with Not Dark Yet (even the casual listener has noticed that until the overdone Make You Feel My Love, every odd numbered track is excellent, and every even numbered track is average) . As for Love and Theft, comparing these two in terms of quality is madness.

Your standouts are:
Spirit on the Water
Workingman’s Blues #2
Nettie Moore
Ain’t Talkin’

Your average Blues-Rocker are:
Rollin’ and Tumblin’
The Levee Gonna Break
Someday Baby

Your over-sentimental pap is:
When the Deal goes Down

- 3 comments by 1 or more people Not publicly viewable

  1. Dan Le Ray

    Have to say I agree with all your standout tracks, though I think it’s significantly better than “Love & Theft”. There seems to be more consideration over the non-blues/rock tracks (‘Levee Gonna Break’ is a possible track skipping moment though), and the standouts are classics in a very Dylanesque vein.

    ‘Workingman’s Blues’ is a lyrical lift from Merle Haggard (I have read), and ‘Nettie Moore’ returns to an older Dylan style, such as the more interesting love ballad elements of “Oh Mercy” – but then, I’m also a big fan of “Time out of Mind”, and the Daniel Lanois production (on both records) is something I think Bob may have benefitted from with the last record. ‘Jack Frost’ (as he calls himself) may not be the top level producer Bob thinks he is.

    But ‘Ain’t Talkin’ is a most fitting ending to the record. As Dylan seems to be still in love with what he’s doing, he lets us know the he “ain’t talkin’...just walkin’”, that is, ploughing on with his inimitable dash of nonchalance mixed with musical genius, but still refusing (his “Chronicles” aside) to explain himself to his public. Letting us know that, despite initial appearances, he is as vital as ever in making records and living on the road, the final chord of the song (and album) moves from a minor to major.

    06 Sep 2006, 00:19

  2. Tiny Montgomery

    Modern Times just doesn’t do it for me. I loved the last two albums but this new one seems like inferior outtakes from those two great CDs. The music seems lackluster like something a bar band would churn out. I listened to it about ten times and put in on the shelf, I doubt that I’ll listen to it much in the future. Check out Johanna Newsom’s new albun called “Ys” for some real musical genius. It’s not out in the stores yet but it’s all over the Net.

    06 Sep 2006, 04:42

  3. Thanks for the feedback guys. I must say, as a whole, it doesn’t really “do it” for me either, I’ve stopped listening to it already really. In many ways I agree with you both. Levee gonna break does need a skipping (oh, one thing I forgot to mention, what’s his recent obsession with levees, rivers, floods, water about? Same stuff appears in L&T. And is Levee Gonna Break talkin’ about Hurricane Katrina at all “people carrying everything they own…no idea where to go”, et.? what youse reckon?). Seriously, though, Dan, nothing needs skipping on L&T, and if it wasn’t for “I Want You”, it would beat Blonde on Blonde to be his best album. It’s just much more interesting musically and lyrically than Modern Times. He doesn’t put a foot wrong on L&T.

    Ah, Joanna has new stuff. Great news, thanks mate. I wouldn’t have known otherwise. Getting it now.

    06 Sep 2006, 15:18

Add a comment

You are not allowed to comment on this entry as it has restricted commenting permissions.

September 2006

Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa Su
Aug |  Today  | Oct
            1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30   



MP3s are available for a limited time and are for sampling purposes only. If you like a band or a song, please buy it at Amazon or elsewhere. Please.

If you’d like your music removed, please email us and we will happily oblige.

Most recent comments

  • Yeah, there's a really nice eclectic mix of styles going on here. Suprised to find out that song was… by on this entry
  • I was watching "So You Think You Can Dance" with my wife and we caught a cool song called "Ramalama … by souris on this entry
  • Hopefully I may see Krug and co as they are playing Glasgow while I'm still there… Already a big f… by on this entry
  • Pleasantly surprised that this came to fruition – lovely formatting too, and the 'start here' idea w… by jack adams on this entry
  • Nice summary – Dragonslayer is indeed immense, I'll be seeing Krug & Co in Sept! May I recommend, if… by holy roar on this entry
Not signed in
Sign in

Powered by BlogBuilder