July 27, 2005

Good Work Undone – Birmingham City LFC

Writing about web page http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/women/4715919.stm

This is nothing sort of disgraceful. Just a few months after the successful women's European Championships and Birmingham City, one of the top flight women's clubs, also my adopted club, are probably going out of existance.

Let's get this in perspective. Birmingham players featured strongly in Euro 2005 – Jo Fletcher, Karen Carney and Alex Scott all played at least two games. Imagine a club with David James, Joe Cole and Gary Neville being on the verge of going out of existance. They've already lost two other England starters, Rachel Yankey and Amanda Barr, in recent weeks, most likely due to the situation there.

Alex Scott.

BCLFC have been in a poor situation financially for a while but had managed to build up a good youth academy system which contributed to BCLFC getting promoted the the national premiership only a few years ago. Karen Carney is merely the most high profile graduate of the system. In fact on the surface it looks like BCLFC had most of the components a club would need to survive, good players, a high profile (relatively speaking, I'm not pretending for a moment women's football has the profile it deserves) and a good youth system. So what went wrong?

Money as usual.

The successful women's clubs are the ones which have the support of their male counterparts. A brief glance at the websites of Arsenal, Charlton and Everton shows that these clubs have given some attention to their ladies' teams. It's probably not a coincidence that Arsenal LFC won the league this year whilst the other two fought it out in the FA Cup final. These clubs have recognised that association with the fastest growing sport in the country is probably a good long term investment, both in terms of prestige and, in the future, financially too.

Karen Carney (centre) with Eni Aluko (left) and Fara Williams (right).

What is less encouraging is the continuing rash of withdrawals by the big clubs. Manchester United recently ended their senior women's team, joining the likes of Sunderland and Cardiff in doing so. It seems like a waste of a genuine opportunity for these clubs, and certainly Manchester United can't be doing it for the same reasons as, say, Leeds United who ended their financial association with Leeds United Ladies FC recently for financial reasons. As it happens LULFC signed a sponsorship deal recently which should see them remain afloat. But with this going on in the background it's saldy unsurprising that Birmingham City have refused to help their female counterparts despite the intervention of Trevor Brooking amongst others. Without a sponsor, like Leeds were fortunate to get, the league will start with nine clubs and the future of all those associated with BCLFC is uncertain.

The most galling bit is this – all BCLFC need to survive is £75,000 a year. Some footballers earn that in four days. Big clubs are happy to waste millions on useless, overpriced prima donnas but won't even reach out to invest (not bail out as there is much potential) in the women's game. Didier Drogba/Joey Barton/Harry Kewell or a thriving club stuffed with top class England players? I know which I'd rather have.

- 9 comments by 1 or more people Not publicly viewable

[Skip to the latest comment]
  1. Bozaboo


    do you feel that disturbance in the force? yep, i'm back and coming to visit. although i'm not 100% sure where the hell you are.

    27 Jul 2005, 22:13

  2. Cheshire.


    27 Jul 2005, 22:58

  3. Bozgnaious

    can we do experiments relating to cats and michael jackson when i come visit?

    28 Jul 2005, 10:57

  4. Carter

    Cruel times indeed. Remind me to tell you about my brother's mate's relationship with Women's Football sometime!

    29 Jul 2005, 12:05

  5. Do Fantasy League. Do my mini-league. Yes, that's right, I'm now doing what approximates to cold-calling in blog comments – yay!

    Details are here should you wish to take part…and we don't mind being beaten by a girl. Much.


    05 Aug 2005, 01:45

  6. Elspeth

    I think they are the only big women's footy team who have completely separate finances from their men's side. All the other clubs make their sposors give both the women and the men money but BCLFC don't. I can't remember where I read that but I remember thinking oh dear.

    13 Aug 2005, 04:16

  7. Not entirely the case, Leeds WFC have different shirt sponsors and the like, but it true to say that BCLFC aren't related to Birmingham men's at all.

    13 Aug 2005, 20:14

  8. savannah

    karen carney is the best

    15 Aug 2005, 19:26

  9. Kainskind

    KC rules in deed. The other BCLFC superstars left and play now for Arsenal, Everton or Charlton. She stayed. I don't care about BCLFC to be honest. If SHE decides to play for an other club, I'd go with her. The best thing for me would be if she played for I.FFC Frankfurt. But I think the best Karen could do is staying in Birmingham. You can't become immortal playing for another club every two years. Why to they love Alessandro del Pierro or Steven Gerrard? Money isn't everything, eh? Alessandro was born in Torino, Karen was born in Birmingham…
    [Shame on the Blues (males) management, male players, …]
    (A friend of mine was joking and told me to pay this 75t, that way I would finally get my date with Karen.)

    03 Sep 2005, 20:10

Add a comment

You are not allowed to comment on this entry as it has restricted commenting permissions.

July 2005

Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa Su
Jun |  Today  | Aug
            1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

Search this blog

Blog archive

Not signed in
Sign in

Powered by BlogBuilder