May 04, 2007

Wuthering Heights – A Rant

I recently saw a film version of the book with Juliette Binoche and Ralph Fiennes, because my opinion of the book is not a high one, and I thought that maybe if I saw a film version the directors divine vision of it (plus a couple of good actors) would improve mine. However, it only served to remind me how very much I despise the book.

I've always hated it, since I opened the first badly written page to the time I closed the overly tragic, cringeworthy last. Granted, the characters are interesting, the plot is complex, but does that make it any good? And, really, the cycle of names drives me mad. When I read a book I want to get the story, I don't want to be banging my head against a wall trying to sort out names and who everyone is the child of.

And the violence. I don't get it. Why do people like it? Heathcliff is a git, a twat, etc, etc. His character is not only frightening, but absurd. A wild spirit from the moors, indeed. Ptsh. And also the kind of love Bronte was portraying is that tragic idealised sort - passionate, obsessive, unstopable, and unlikely to occur unless you're a stalker. The book seems like a teenager's (or in this case, a woman in her late twenties) way to pass the time, not a literary work of genius.

I can't believe some people actually think Emily Bronte was a better writer than Charlotte.

Rant done.

- 3 comments by 1 or more people Not publicly viewable

  1. But did you actually read it all the way through? I’m no fan of it either but I haven’t forced myself to endure it. Are you one of that breed who, after starting a book, feel they owe it the recognition of grinding through to the bitter end without chucking it aside?

    07 May 2007, 13:21

  2. I did read it all the way through, yes, but not because I felt I owed the author anything, although I’m sure she was nice and all that. I did it because I thought it might have an incredible ending, as so many people seem to think it’s worth the read.

    07 May 2007, 13:52

  3. Justin

    Don’t let them fool you, Gwen. These are the same people who try to perpetuate the myth that Ulysses is worth the migraines. I muscled my way through the first quarter of it before I realized how They were all full of shit. I’ll never get that time back.

    08 May 2007, 00:16

Add a comment

You are not allowed to comment on this entry as it has restricted commenting permissions.

May 2007

Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa Su
Apr |  Today  | Jun
   1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31         

Search this blog

Blog archive


Most recent comments

  • Thanks for the advice, George – I was blown away by Porphyria's Lover, and will look into Pascale Pe… by Gwen on this entry
  • Hmm. I get the feeling I'm missing some kind of context, but the opening tercets are too interesting… by George Ttoouli on this entry
  • I wandered into your blog while searching James McAvoy's pictures online. I totally fell in love wit… by Yurong on this entry
  • I really love the movie,the story has moved me.James McAvoy is so attractive by JC on this entry
  • Yes, a very smart one, too :) by Gwen Kent on this entry
Not signed in
Sign in

Powered by BlogBuilder