All 2 entries tagged Coalition

Government promoting use of AV–like procedures

Although the referendum on AV for electing the house of commons has been lost, there nevertheless seems to be an emerging consensus for its use to elect other officials.

The government is proposing that both police commissioners and city mayors be elected by a variant of AV - the Supplementary Vote where voters only record their first and second preferences. This procedure is already used to elect the London mayor. This voting method is in the police bill and the localism bill currently before parliament. It makes good sense to use a preferential voting procedure to ensure that extreme unrepresentative minority candidates do not get in as can happen with first past the post. The requirement of that the winner gets majority support is an important safeguard.

These bills are in the names of the cabinet ministers responsible, both prominent Tory supporters of the NoToAV campaign during the referendum. Teresa May, the Home Secretary, is proposing the Police Reform and Social Responsibility bill, and Eric Pickles the Localism bill to increase the number of directly elected city mayors.

It would be interesting to know how they can justify proposing methods that they have condemned so unequivocally.

Dennis Leech : 11 May 2011 12:42 |  Tags: Alternative Vote Coalition Elected Mayors Police Commissioners Referendum |  Comments (0) |  Close comments |  Report a problem

Coalition supporters talking up the debt problem

Coalition supporters are exaggerating the debt problem. They have not got a democratic mandate from the election and the only argument they have in favour of cutting public expenditure is sheer economic necessity. There is no alternative, as Margaret Thatcher said of her rather similar policy.

The size of the deficit is undoubtedly a problem, the difference between tax receipts and public expenditure is at almost unprecedented levels due to the recession causing a sudden fall in tax revenue. This is a problem that needs addressing because it is unsustainable. It cannot be allowed to go on indefinitely. Labour says the deficit should be halved in four years, while the government say it can be eliminated completely by the end of the parliament without harming the economy.

But whatever our policy on the deficit, we should be clear about what we are talking about. Having a deficit is not the same as having a high national debt.

But coalition politicians are taking figures from the national debt and using them out of context to scare us. They use figures on the national debt inappropriately.

They all say that interest on government debt is costing us £120 million A DAY. They always stress the A DAY bit. It sounds a lot. But it is out of context. It translates to about £43 billion in a year. But that is only 3 percent of GDP. (In 2010 GDP was estimated to be £1454 billion.)

Interest payments of 3 percent is a very small figure in fact. (And anyway about 70 percent of government debt is held by UK residents. We are paying this interest to ourselves not foreigners, but that is another matter.)

Furthermore, the UK national debt is not actually high, either by historical standards or internationally. So it is disingenuous to complain about it.

National debt fluctuates quite widely over the years but it has never been so large that there was a problem financing it, and the UK has never defaulted. The highest level of national debt was just after the second world war when it was almost 240 percent of gross domestic product. (Interestingly the baby boomers 'inherited' a much higher level of debt than today's.) It came down steadily until it reached its lowest level in recent years, 25 percent in 1991. It started to go up again and reached 42 percent in 1997 when Labour was elected. Gordon Brown's prudence got it back down to 29 percent in 2002. It was 36 percent in 2008 before the financial crash and is now increasing rapidly. The estimate for 2011 is 60 percent. But this is still a relatively low figure, as the following graph shows.

Dennis Leech : 31 Mar 2011 16:56 |  Tags: Coalition National Debt |  Comments (0) |  Close comments |  Report a problem