April 25, 2005

Feeble cliffhangers

I'm enjoying the new series of Dr Who, but I was surprised by the incompetence of the editing recently. They're including a trailer for next week at the end of every episode, and the last story was a two-parter in which part 1 ended with a cliffhanger in which everyone is in mortal danger. So you might think that showing a trailer immediately after the cliffhanger which clearly shows everyone alive and well slightly undercuts your narrative arc. But apparently this wasn't an oversight; here's an email from the BBC (via YakYak ):-

We're sorry that your enjoyment of the new "Doctor Who" series on BBC One has been marred by the trailers for the following episode. The aim of these short trailers is to demonstrate the range and tone of storytelling on offer week by week and we believe it's always important to tease the audience with details of the next adventure. Having said that, we appreciate that a trail that comes midway in a two-part story needs to be handled especially carefully. With hindsight, the BBC agrees that we probably did give too much away within the content of the trail for episode 5. The reason we did this is that we didn't want to leave our very young audience anxious for a whole week about the safety of the Doctor. In future we will take more care to find a balance between not spoiling the impact of the cliffhanger while leaving children thrilled but without anxiety.

It's nice, I suppose, that someone at the BBC is thinking about the anxiety levels of their very young audience, but isn't the whole point of cliffhangers that they should induce, well, anxiety? I remember Tom Baker and Jon Pertwee (the Doctors I watched when younger) routinely being choked, shot, zapped, exploded and lord knows what else at the end of the episode, and I survived without trailers showing them alive and well next week.

Mind you, Doctor Who has some way to go to beat Dragonball Z in the undercutting-your-own-narrative stakes. Also from YakYak, PurpleChair writes:-

"At the end of one episode, Goku (the main character) was poisoned by some kind of space virus that was going to kill him, and no-one knew the cure. There followed a trailer for the next episode, in which the other characters search for some magic bean that they think will cure him. The excited voiceover concluded thusly:

WILL GOKU LIVE? FIND OUT IN OUR NEXT EPISODE: GOKU LIVES!

Wonderful.


- One comment Not publicly viewable

  1. It's all still nowhere near as bad as Sky's trailers for Buffy the Vampire Slayer…

    26 Apr 2005, 13:53


Add a comment

You are not allowed to comment on this entry as it has restricted commenting permissions.

Trackbacks

Search this blog

Tags

Blog archive

Loading…

Most recent comments

  • I am looking for a children's book I read in the early 1970s about a young girl who found a witch li… by Maggie on this entry
  • Thanks, John. There are always more books to be remembered, so it's good to have a decent source. by John Dale on this entry
  • I'm a bit late to the party, but in the future, you can always ask at http://www.reddit.com/r/tipofm… by John on this entry
  • I remember we had a series of books when I was around 10 years old in the early 80's. One of the boo… by Andrew Uttley on this entry
  • The trainers look great. I have been reviewing stuff on my blogs for a while and is actually the foc… by on this entry
Not signed in
Sign in

Powered by BlogBuilder
© MMXIV